Will My Slip and Fall Case Settle or Go to Trial?

April 3, 2025

Will My Slip and Fall Case Settle or Go to Trial?

Slip and fall accidents can lead to serious injuries, costly medical bills, and lost wages. If you're considering filing a claim, one of your biggest concerns may be whether your case will settle or go to trial. While most personal injury claims reach a settlement, some cases require a court battle. Several factors influence whether an agreement is reached or if the case moves forward in court.


Factors That Influence Settlement or Trial

Several factors determine whether a slip and fall case is resolved through a settlement or proceeds to trial. The severity of the injury, the strength of the evidence, and the willingness of the property owner or insurance company to negotiate all play a role. If liability is clear and the damages are well-documented, the opposing party may be more inclined to offer a fair settlement. However, if fault is disputed or the insurance company refuses to pay a reasonable amount, litigation may be necessary.


The Benefits of Settling

Settling a case often provides a faster resolution and avoids the uncertainty of a trial. When a settlement is reached, the injured party receives compensation without waiting for a court date, which can take months or even years. Additionally, settlements eliminate the risk of losing at trial and provide a guaranteed outcome. Many property owners and insurance companies prefer to settle rather than face the expenses and unpredictability of a courtroom battle.


The Risks of Going to Trial

While trials can sometimes lead to higher compensation, they come with risks. The final decision is in the hands of a judge or jury, and there is no guarantee of a favorable outcome. Trials also require extensive preparation, which can add stress and prolong the process. Additionally, legal expenses and court fees can reduce the final payout. For these reasons, many injury victims prefer to resolve their cases through negotiations rather than litigation.


The Role of Legal Representation

An experienced attorney can significantly affect how a slip and fall case unfolds. A legal advocate will assess the details of the case, gather necessary evidence, and negotiate with insurance companies to secure fair compensation. If the opposing party refuses to offer a reasonable settlement, an attorney can present a strong case in court. Whether the case settles or proceeds to trial, having legal support increases the likelihood of a favorable outcome.


Deciding whether to settle or go to trial depends on several factors, including the strength of the case, the willingness of the insurance company to negotiate, and the potential risks of litigation. While settlements are often the preferred route due to their speed and certainty, some cases require a trial to secure fair compensation. Seeking legal representation can help ensure that your rights are protected and that you receive the compensation you deserve. If you’ve been injured in a slip and fall accident in Charleston, WV, reach out to Webb Law Centre PLLC to discuss your options.

Car accident scene with damaged black car in front of a police car.
August 21, 2025
Injured in a Car Crash? What Charleston, WV Drivers Need to Know About Getting Compensation
Laptop, notebook with pens, papers, and coffee cup on a green table outdoors.
August 14, 2025
CHARLESTON, W.Va. — Charles “Rusty” Webb, founder of The Webb Law Centre, announced today that his firm is expanding its nationwide review of kratom-related injury and wrongful death cases following an NBC Nightly News report on a beverage containing kratom and kava root. The August 2025 NBC segment highlighted growing social media warnings about the herbal supplement “Feel Free,” which contains kava root — touted for its relaxing effects — and kratom, a plant native to Southeast Asia known for its stimulant and opioid-like effects. “Kratom is still being marketed in ways that obscure its risks,” Webb said. “The NBC investigation underscores what the FDA’s been warning about — there are serious safety concerns without proper education, and people need to understand their legal options if they’ve been harmed.” The U.S. Food and Drug Administration has issued multiple warnings about kratom’s potential to cause addiction, liver damage, and death. Webb’s firm is currently reviewing cases involving: Fatal overdoses linked to kratom use Severe addiction requiring medical treatment Organ failure or other life-threatening complications Health care professionals or whistleblowers with relevant information With more than 30 years of legal experience in high-stakes toxic tort and product liability claims, Webb was one of the first attorneys to formally launch a coordinated litigation strategy targeting kratom manufacturers and distributors earlier this year. “The parallels to early opioid litigation are striking,” Webb said. “These cases can protect consumers and prevent another public health crisis.” About Rusty Webb Rusty Webb is the founder of The Webb Law Centre in Charleston, West Virginia. He has served in the West Virginia House of Delegates and has represented individuals and communities in precedent-setting complex tort, environmental, and public interest litigation. Media Contact:  Webb Law Centre PLLC  714 Venture Drive Charleston, WV 25309 www.webblawcentre.com
Wooden gavel resting on a block with blurred books in the background.
August 13, 2025
Charles R. “Rusty” Webb, founder of The Webb Law Centre, PLLC, has been nominated to Attorney and Practice Magazine’s 2025 “Top 10 Personal Injury Law Attorney — Raising the Bar” directory for West Virginia.
Gavel, Lady Justice statue, and books on a desk in a sunlit office, symbolizing law and justice.
August 13, 2025
Charles R. “Rusty” Webb, founder of The Webb Law Centre, PLLC, has been nominated to The American Association of Attorneys Advocates™ (AAAA) 2025 Dedication to Outstanding Advocacy Top 10 Personal Injury Law Attorney directory for West Virginia.
Statue of Lady Justice holding scales and sword against a dark background.
August 13, 2025
Charles R. “Rusty” Webb, founder of The Webb Law Centre, PLLC, has been selected for Membership in Lawyers of Distinction for 2025, recognizing professional achievement and peer recognition in the practice of law.
Statue of Lady Justice and gavel on a desk, next to books and a laptop.
August 13, 2025
Charles R. “Rusty” Webb, founder of The Webb Law Centre, PLLC, has been selected to join the nation’s top trial lawyers as a member of the Distinguished Justice Advocates (DJA) Charter—an honor extended to fewer than 1% of attorneys nationwide.
Statue of Lady Justice holding scales and sword against a dark background.
August 13, 2025
Charleston, West Virginia Attorney Best of 2025 by Business Rate
August 8, 2025
CHARLESTON, W.Va. — Charles “Rusty” Webb, founder of the Webb Law Centre, is stepping into the national spotlight as one of the first attorneys to formally launch a litigation strategy focused on kratom—a controversial botanical compound tied to addiction, organ damage, and fatal overdoses. As kratom continues to be sold widely in gas stations and online, the FDA has stepped up its scrutiny, issuing multiple public health warnings and cracking down on manufacturers for deceptive marketing and unapproved claims. With mounting injuries and fatalities, Webb believes kratom may become the next mass tort litigation wave—comparable to early opioid lawsuits. “Kratom is marketed as ‘natural’ and ‘safe,’ but many of the same red flags we saw in opioid cases are here again,” said Webb. “It’s time to hold these companies accountable.” National Legal Review Underway The Webb Law Centre is now reviewing kratom-related injury cases nationwide. The firm is accepting inquiries from: Families impacted by fatal overdoses involving kratom Individuals experiencing severe addiction or organ failure Healthcare professionals and whistleblowers Attorneys seeking co-counsel relationships on emerging kratom litigation With more than 30 years of legal experience and a background in high-stakes toxic tort and product liability claims, Rusty Webb is well-positioned to lead this emerging legal front. “We’ve seen firsthand what happens when dangerous products are allowed to spread unchecked,” Webb said. “We won’t let history repeat itself.” About Rusty Webb Rusty Webb is a nationally recognized trial lawyer based in Charleston, West Virginia. He has served in the West Virginia House of Delegates and has litigated precedent-setting injury cases throughout the region. Webb is known for his work in complex torts, environmental cases, and public interest litigation.  Media Contact Webb Law Centre 714 Venture Drive, Charleston, WV 25309 www.webblawcentre.com
August 8, 2025
As kratom gains national attention for its potential health risks and legal scrutiny, individuals harmed by this herbal supplement are starting to ask the critical question: "Do I have a case?" Attorney Charles "Rusty" Webb of The Webb Law Centre in Charleston, West Virginia is one of the few lawyers in the country focused on kratom litigation. Here's what you need to know if you're considering filing a lawsuit against a kratom manufacturer or distributor. KEY TAKEAWAYS: Kratom is legal in many states but unregulated, leading to major risks for consumers. Lawsuits are emerging over injuries tied to kratom addiction, overdose, and death. The Webb Law Centre is currently reviewing cases involving wrongful death, liver failure, addiction, and adulterated kratom products. If your injury is tied to a known brand-such as Feel Free tonic-you may have a strong case. Kratom cases are NOT class action-they are mass torts, meaning your injuries must be evaluated individually. THE LEGAL LANDSCAPE The U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has not approved kratom for any medical use, and multiple states are now considering bans or regulations. Some manufacturers market kratom as a dietary supplement, sidestepping regulation-despite its well-documented links to addiction, hallucination, seizures, liver damage, and even death. "These are serious cases, and people deserve the truth about what they're putting into their bodies," says Rusty Webb. "Families are grieving, and they're shocked that something so dangerous is being sold openly in gas stations and online." WHAT MAKES A KRATOM CASE STRONG? Each case is fact-specific, but common threads among strong cases include: Use of a known kratom product linked to harm Documented medical diagnosis or treatment Sudden or escalating addiction symptoms Liver failure, overdose, or death Underage access or deceptive marketing THE WEBB LAW CENTRE APPROACH Unlike large national firms chasing volume, The Webb Law Centre takes a personal, investigative approach to each case. They work with toxicologists, addiction specialists, and medical experts to build litigation-readyclaims. "We don't just take your case-we build it," says Webb. 
August 8, 2025
Kratom—a herbal supplement derived from the Mitragyna speciosa plant—has gained popularity in gas stations, head shops, and online marketplaces across the U.S. But behind its claims of pain relief and mood enhancement, there is a growing wave of lawsuits and questions. Can you sue a kratom manufacturer if you or a loved one has been harmed? Attorney Charles "Rusty" Webb of The Webb Law Centre offers clear guidance for families seeking justice. What Makes Kratom Legally Actionable? According to Webb, kratom's legal exposure centers around two critical areas: Failure to Warn: "Many manufacturers fail to provide adequate warnings about kratom's addictive properties or its interaction with other medications," Webb explains. "That alone may create liability.” Product Contamination or Mislabeling: Some products have been found to contain dangerously high levels of mitragynine, synthetic additives, or contaminants. "When a product is mislabeled or tainted, that crosses the line into negligence," says Webb. The Legal Grounds for Filing a Kratom Lawsuit To successfully bring a case, plaintiffs generally must prove: The kratom product was defective, mislabeled, or lacked adequate warnings. The manufacturer or distributor was negligent. The product directly caused injury, addiction, or death. "It’s not enough that someone used kratom," says Webb. "We must establish a clear line between the product and the harm.” Who Can File a Lawsuit? Cases may be brought by: Individuals who became addicted or suffered organ failure, stroke, or other health complications after using kratom. Family members of individuals who died following kratom ingestion. Parents of teens or young adults who purchased kratom in gas stations without clear warnings. Why These Cases Are Growing As more states begin regulating or banning kratom, and as the FDA continues to issue warnings, awareness is building. "We’re seeing patterns across multiple states, especially where kratom is sold over the counter with little to no oversight," Webb says. "This is beginning to mirror early opioid litigation.” The Role of the Webb Law Centre Based in Charleston, West Virginia, The Webb Law Centre is one of the first firms in the region to actively investigate kratom-related claims. "We take these cases personally," Webb notes. "Many of our clients come to us after losing a son, daughter, or spouse. They’re not just looking for compensation—they want accountability.”